1. If “gender” is social, and academics like Judith Butler have been arguing that for decades, why are they trying to offer biological proof now? And how does that override chromosomes and gametes?
2. Any brain in a male body is a male brain, and our brains are a collection of impulses within that body. It can’t be female in a male body just like a liver or heart cannot be. There is no other way to label it.
3. Where is the scan to prove the opposite sex brain is in a body? Require that before any hormones/surgeries so “detransition” will never happen and there are no misdiagnoses. Why isn’t that required?
If there were any veracity to this then the argument of whether Kid should have Blocker / HRT would be over. 1 $500 MRI scan would prove beyond contest that the kid had a "Trans Brain". BUT IT'S BULLSHIT.
Here is a doozy! How about doctors will only prescribe cross sex hormones to any adult who can show dimorphism in a brain scan! No more AGPs !
An old friend of mine who watched a LOT of porn sent me a "study" on "jumping genes: to "prove" transgenderism. I told him that, if that were true, he could expect an arm growing out his forehead 🙄
The "conservative" accusation is a tiresome, grossly overplayed distraction from absurd arguments.It's as meaningless as calling someone "transphobic".
Transgenderism IS a mental illness. Nobody will ever convince me that it's anything but a mental illness, no matter how many letters they have after their name, nor how many bullshit qualifications they may have.
Also, along with it's emotional & psychological impacts, estrogen causes very painful physical conditions during peri-menopause, such as De Quervains tenosynovitis, which REALLY HURTS.
p.s: I've been looking through the 'you're kidding, right?' back catalogue for the "There's sperm & egg, There ain't no spegg" song but I can't find it - anyone who knows where I can find Karen singing this song, can you link me to it? It cheers me up no end! Thanks in advance xx
Not correct Transgenderism/Transsexualism is a state of being. Someone takes opposite sex hormones of has surgery for the purposes of looking like a member of the opposite sex they are Transgender/ Transsexual that's all it takes. The vast majority of them are simply indulging a fetish and a fetish is not a mental illness.
Gender Identity Disorder IS a mental illness but only a small number of those who seek transition actually have it.
Fair enough, a mental illness or a fetish, either way both are psychological in nature, they are psychological at their core - it isn't biological/medical/surgical intervention these people need, unlike women going through peri-menopause. A man walks into a Dr's surgery, perfectly healthy body, says "I'm a woman because I say so" or "I 'feel like' a woman on the inside " and he gets HRT within around 2 appointments. A woman walks into a Dr's surgery with all manner of very real physical symptoms and can she get HRT? Can she get ANY help at all? Not in the UK she can't. I know that from personal experience and That's my point.
I do know the difference between transsexual, transvestite & autogynophiIe, you know, I just don't care about it anymore. The extreme injustice to actual women is just too much.
That's just it there is no difference really. The only issue is some transsexuals have GID (a mental disorder). Most do not. The likes of Buck Angel, Blair White seem to use the term Transsexual as if it were a diagnosable condition. It isn't Gender Identity Disorder is the diagnosable condition, but a person with GID may never transition depending on how bad it is.
Sorry to hear about your issues with getting HRT, that could be your particular NHS Trust. My mother has been o HRT since her hysterectomy and my sister-in-law who is 55 and menopausal has had about 4 different types of HRT until she found one which worked for her. Although both have female GP's!
Wow the selective cognition of these AGP's never ceases to amaze me. They read a small section of a study that seems to support their narrative and ignore the rest of it. Clutching at fucking straws.
In which as well as having carried out his own research Guillamon reviewed all the previous studies back to the 1970's. As in the most sited study Savic & Arver 2015 he noted that the ONLY cohort with any dimorphic shift in pre-HRT brain structure were the Homosexual cohort. NONE of the heterosexual subject showed any structural differences to the control males.
Even then it was only a subsection of the homosexual subject which showed any significant swing away from the controls and that was those who had under virillized (i.e. Twinks!)
None of the twinks had female brains, they had under masculinised male brains. and Absolutely NONE of the Transvestite / AGP group had any dimorphism away from the standard male controls pre HRT. Even after HRT all they got was some minute cortical thinning and an insignificant shift in the grey/white matter ratio.
Three points:
1. If “gender” is social, and academics like Judith Butler have been arguing that for decades, why are they trying to offer biological proof now? And how does that override chromosomes and gametes?
2. Any brain in a male body is a male brain, and our brains are a collection of impulses within that body. It can’t be female in a male body just like a liver or heart cannot be. There is no other way to label it.
3. Where is the scan to prove the opposite sex brain is in a body? Require that before any hormones/surgeries so “detransition” will never happen and there are no misdiagnoses. Why isn’t that required?
Ding, Ding, Ding We have a Winner! EXACTLY.
If there were any veracity to this then the argument of whether Kid should have Blocker / HRT would be over. 1 $500 MRI scan would prove beyond contest that the kid had a "Trans Brain". BUT IT'S BULLSHIT.
Here is a doozy! How about doctors will only prescribe cross sex hormones to any adult who can show dimorphism in a brain scan! No more AGPs !
Imagine the meltdowns after *that* policy change?!?
Of course it would never happen, even if there was discovered such a basis...
I would like to be the one to deliver the news.
"Nope, scan shows you have a normal male brain, Now fuck off and don't darken my door again" 🤣
I think I'd just about pay to see you do it too, tbh!
Brian is terminally stupid, and the owner of a male brain. Tragic...
ALLLL the brains that have been studied around the world - there is NOT ONE hailed, celebrated, whatever; as a "transgender" brain.
Why is that? In this pro-troon climate?
Because... It. Doesn't. Exist.
An old friend of mine who watched a LOT of porn sent me a "study" on "jumping genes: to "prove" transgenderism. I told him that, if that were true, he could expect an arm growing out his forehead 🙄
😂🤣🤭
The "conservative" accusation is a tiresome, grossly overplayed distraction from absurd arguments.It's as meaningless as calling someone "transphobic".
Transgenderism IS a mental illness. Nobody will ever convince me that it's anything but a mental illness, no matter how many letters they have after their name, nor how many bullshit qualifications they may have.
Also, along with it's emotional & psychological impacts, estrogen causes very painful physical conditions during peri-menopause, such as De Quervains tenosynovitis, which REALLY HURTS.
p.s: I've been looking through the 'you're kidding, right?' back catalogue for the "There's sperm & egg, There ain't no spegg" song but I can't find it - anyone who knows where I can find Karen singing this song, can you link me to it? It cheers me up no end! Thanks in advance xx
Not correct Transgenderism/Transsexualism is a state of being. Someone takes opposite sex hormones of has surgery for the purposes of looking like a member of the opposite sex they are Transgender/ Transsexual that's all it takes. The vast majority of them are simply indulging a fetish and a fetish is not a mental illness.
Gender Identity Disorder IS a mental illness but only a small number of those who seek transition actually have it.
Fair enough, a mental illness or a fetish, either way both are psychological in nature, they are psychological at their core - it isn't biological/medical/surgical intervention these people need, unlike women going through peri-menopause. A man walks into a Dr's surgery, perfectly healthy body, says "I'm a woman because I say so" or "I 'feel like' a woman on the inside " and he gets HRT within around 2 appointments. A woman walks into a Dr's surgery with all manner of very real physical symptoms and can she get HRT? Can she get ANY help at all? Not in the UK she can't. I know that from personal experience and That's my point.
I do know the difference between transsexual, transvestite & autogynophiIe, you know, I just don't care about it anymore. The extreme injustice to actual women is just too much.
That's just it there is no difference really. The only issue is some transsexuals have GID (a mental disorder). Most do not. The likes of Buck Angel, Blair White seem to use the term Transsexual as if it were a diagnosable condition. It isn't Gender Identity Disorder is the diagnosable condition, but a person with GID may never transition depending on how bad it is.
Sorry to hear about your issues with getting HRT, that could be your particular NHS Trust. My mother has been o HRT since her hysterectomy and my sister-in-law who is 55 and menopausal has had about 4 different types of HRT until she found one which worked for her. Although both have female GP's!
Brian here has zero in common with: a) women and girls
b) people with DSDs
c) gay men and lesbian women
and should leave anyone with one or more of these characteristics tf alone. The end.
16.12 WHAT?! This stupid prick of a man IS A FATHER! 🤦♀️
I was thinking to myself I bet he’s a dad.
This awful man seems to have been simply *everywhere* online this week.
I'm already heartily sick of him and I honestly am convinced that he's going to announce the publication of his book any day now.
🥇
Wow the selective cognition of these AGP's never ceases to amaze me. They read a small section of a study that seems to support their narrative and ignore the rest of it. Clutching at fucking straws.
The most comprehensive study of this nonsense was carried out by Guillamon Et al 2016.https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4987404/
In which as well as having carried out his own research Guillamon reviewed all the previous studies back to the 1970's. As in the most sited study Savic & Arver 2015 he noted that the ONLY cohort with any dimorphic shift in pre-HRT brain structure were the Homosexual cohort. NONE of the heterosexual subject showed any structural differences to the control males.
Even then it was only a subsection of the homosexual subject which showed any significant swing away from the controls and that was those who had under virillized (i.e. Twinks!)
None of the twinks had female brains, they had under masculinised male brains. and Absolutely NONE of the Transvestite / AGP group had any dimorphism away from the standard male controls pre HRT. Even after HRT all they got was some minute cortical thinning and an insignificant shift in the grey/white matter ratio.
Where's the website you quoted (friendly PDF)?
Was it the so-called "virped" site?
https://virped.org/
#CraysAnatomy
LOL 😂
Troons will try every which way to justify their perversions.
I Love you Karen! Keep up the great work!
"Gendered/Sexed" brain theories were debunked as junk science many times over, but these men keep resurrecting this bullshit.